Home Unfiltered Articles Players Baseball Prospectus
Basketball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

Click here for Important Basketball Prospectus Premium Information!

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Tough Acts to Follow (11/28)
Next Article >>
The Kidd Factor (11/29)

November 28, 2012
Early Surprises
Last Year's Results

by Kevin Pelton


After spending the last two days looking forward by considering the most extreme in-season projections combining performance to date with SCHOENE's preseason benchmarks--most improved and biggest drops--today it's time to look back. I did the same exercise at this point of the 2011-12 season (in January due to the late post-lockout start).

Using Dougstats.com's player stats by day, I was able to reconstruct approximately how each player on both lists performed after the articles were published, giving us an idea how accurate the in-season method proved. First, here are last year's early overachievers. Pre is SCHOENE's preseason projection, "In" is the in-season update and "Rem" is the player's winning percentage the remainder of the season. "Min" is minutes played thereafter; note that one player, Damion James, did not play at all due to injury.

Player                 Pre    In     Rem    Min
Daniel Green          .470   .585   .558   1218
Vladimir Radmanovic   .436   .543   .448    442
Spencer Hawes         .462   .566   .507    596
MarShon Brooks        .386   .489   .345   1241
Nikola Vucevic        .410   .505   .425    637
Paul Millsap          .556   .646   .611   1682
Joe Johnson           .483   .569   .568   1542
Kawhi Leonard         .410   .496   .585   1147
Isaiah Thomas         .392   .478   .560   1447
Chandler Parsons      .398   .481   .465   1492
Average               .440   .536   .507 1144.4

And the slow starters:

Player                 Pre    In     Rem    Min
Shawne Williams       .524   .389   .381    319
Jamaal Magloire       .355   .254   .285    208
Toney Douglas         .577   .476   .350    313
Patrick Patterson     .520   .428   .358   1226
Austin Daye           .508   .417   .378    463
Damion James          .367   .297     -       0
Landry Fields         .520   .450   .440   1435
Mehmet Okur           .515   .446   .322    110
Tyrus Thomas          .555   .496   .343    799
Glen Davis            .401   .343   .408   1089
Average               .515   .431   .372  595.9

What stands out right away is the enormous difference between the two lists. The players who started fast faded thereafter, even more so than the in-season projection suggested--though they still outplayed their SCHOENE projection entering the year. By contrast, the poor starters played far worse than their in-season projections and were nowhere close to preseason expectations. Overall, the in-season update removes about a third of the average error in projecting the remainder of the season, justifying the effort.

One clue as to why these groups could fare so differently the rest of the season comes from the minutes column. Naturally, the overachievers got more opportunity to continue to play, even when they declined. Meanwhile, the poor play of the second group sent them to the bench, limiting their opportunity to prove the early play was a fluke.

There does appear to be more to the issue than that, however. Even among the four players who saw at least 750 minutes of action the rest of the way, only Glen Davis matched or beat his updated projection. (In fact, Davis ended up playing better than SCHOENE predicted at the start of the year.) Landry Fields came close to his in-season projection, while Patrick Patterson and Tyrus Thomas maintained their poor level of play all season. In Thomas' case, conditioning was the culprit, while Patterson's regression was largely mysterious, especially considering that he's played well as a starter this season.

Playing well in the early going proved slightly less telling in terms of long-term prospects. While fast starts portended that rookies Kawhi Leonard, Chandler Parsons and Isaiah Thomas would make the All-Rookie Team, fellow first-year players MarShon Brooks and Nikola Vucevic fell off dramatically. Brooks was even worse than his college translation suggested, and is now struggling to get playing time in Brooklyn.

The better non-rookies were projected entering the season, the more they tended to maintain their strong early play. That's true of veterans Joe Johnson and Paul Millsap, as well as emerging Daniel Green. Spencer Hawes and Vladimir Radmanovic largely returned to their lesser early caliber of play.

The one factor I'd like to study more in the future is how the shape of a player's stat line affects the validity of early-season performance. Shooting, especially from beyond the arc, tends to be more volatile than statistics where the denominator is total plays on the floor (assists, steals, blocks, usage) or all missed shots (rebounding). Of course, that also means we should be more skeptical of preseason projections for shooting, so in practice the in-season updates tend to weigh all factors about the same. I'm not sure whether that would hold up to increased scrutiny.

Kevin Pelton is an author of Basketball Prospectus. You can contact Kevin by clicking here or click here to see Kevin's other articles.

0 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Tough Acts to Follow (11/28)
Next Article >>
The Kidd Factor (11/29)

State of Basketball Prospectus: A Brief Anno...
Tuesday Truths: March-at-Last Edition
Easy Bubble Solver: The Triumphant Return
Premium Article Bubbles of their Own Making: Villanova, Temp...
Tuesday Truths: Crunch Time Edition

Premium Article Tough Acts to Follow: What About Ohio State?

2012-12-03 - Like the 2010 Heat: Lakers' Similarity
2012-11-30 - Premium Article Go Fish: Dallas Searches for PG Answer
2012-11-29 - The Kidd Factor: The Knicks Without Jason
2012-11-28 - Premium Article Early Surprises: Last Year's Results
2012-11-27 - Premium Article Early Surprises: Underachievers
2012-11-26 - Premium Article Early Surprises: Overachievers
2012-11-21 - As Sweet by Any Speed: Jack Taylor's 138 Poi...

Basketball Prospectus Home  |  Terms of Service  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us
Copyright © 1996-2017 Prospectus Entertainment Ventures, LLC.